I REALLY need opinions on my story! It’s pretty short, 3 par. and easy to read! Please help?
Take a minute or two to read my story below. This isn’t the final draft, but I’m turning this draft in tomorrow and I want someone else’s opinion on my story. Is it good? Horrible? Over dramatic? Boring? Interesting? ANY ANSWER is appreciated, don’t be shy!
I believe that we were born to be here in this time, this moment, this place. This was easy to believe as I stood gazing up at the most spectacular display known to man, something we have all stopped to see at some point in our lives, something that has roused a resounding and brilliant sense of awe in all of us. Perhaps the fact that we were finally there, in the sweltering, muggy Amazon rainforest, teeming with life and a stunning sense of adventure, had already inspired us all. Maybe this was true, but I think the reason we students and teachers alike stopped in our tracks was the fact that, for most of us, we were truly seeing the night sky for the very first time.
I had rushed through many places and events in my past, but there are times in all of our lives that widen our eyes to the fact that yes, this moment is real, and it is our purpose to enjoy it. For me, it was seeing the stars — an unexplainable number of tiny lights, the stretch of varying shades of brilliant turquoise and faded white we call the Milky Way — that kept me entranced. I’d never seen anything like it; maybe in pictures taken by NASA, or in a Space documentary I saw on Discovery Channel. But of course, no picture can match the feeling of standing where I stood then, on the banks of the Tambopata River in the Amazon jungle, no lights to dim the sky but the ones so far above me. It truly was as if the earth had stood still, just for a moment, a moment that I could drag on forever as long as I simply stood there and kept looking up. No words were exchanged between any of us, the thirty some people standing there for ten, maybe fifteen minutes — it didn’t matter — all of us feeling the exact same way: insignificant under such a vast, endless display of lights, and amazed into silence. Well, that’s how we tried to describe the feeling afterwards, when we finally picked up our bags and headed off to the lodge to sleep. But very soon we gave up trying to find words to exchange; we fell silent as we stumbled through the dark lodge, without electricity, trying to find our rooms, knowing that conversation was pointless when we were all, for the moment, thinking the same thing.
I tried to remember what exactly had caused the prolonged pause, the group of us slowing to a stop and losing ourselves in the silence, spellbound by our own thoughts as we looked up at the sky. All I could remember was thinking that I didn’t really care about the mosquitos eating me alive as I stood in the sand, temporarily forgetting about how tired and sweaty and hungry I was. I could have laid down in the sand, leaned against my backpack, and fallen asleep; that’s how long we stood on the banks of that river. Because rarely before then had I considered that maybe I don’t stop enough, just to be there, in the moment, at that time, in that place. Maybe I worry too much about the past, regretting, or maybe I worry too much about the future. When did regret get me anywhere? When did worrying about the trivial things help me out in the end? At some point, everyone realizes how foolish it is to constantly look ahead. Because occasionally, if you just stop for a moment, however briefly, and look, you’ll be able to see the stars.
__________
Thank you for reading ~ Please take the time to answer! =)
ylime - oh…sorry if I didn’t put this in the description… this is a Personal Narrative writing assignment for school. Not a "story".
I believe that we were born to be here in this time, this moment, this place…
Your opener got my attention. Very good opener.
Then you veered off the path. Do I have to travel to the Amazon to see stars..is this what the Amazon offers?
Amazon rain forest, teeming with life…..what kind?
turquoise and faded white we call the Milky Way — that kept me entranced. I’d never seen anything like it…..nice construction. I began to see what you saw.
we gave up trying to find words to exchange; we fell silent. ..hmmmm nice,nice.
I tried to remember what exactly had caused the prolonged pause… Hey! you wandered again! Great flow, here! ..but.. What exactly had caused the prolonged pause??
Maybe I worry too much about the past, regretting, or maybe I worry too much about the future. When did regret get me anywhere? When did worrying about the trivial things help me out in the end? At some point, everyone realizes how foolish it is to constantly look ……..
hmmmmm! you are doing it again! You have opened a very intriguing door for me and then shut it….tell me more about yourself, here. Why are you at the Amazon basin
if you just stop for a moment, however briefly, and look, you’ll be able to see the stars…Wow! Where would that put me if I read more?
You have talent as distant as those stars..and as close as their light.
You need to stand on the banks of "self" and take a moment to see the stars in you that I do…sometimes we stumble through a darkness looking for stars..like yours.
April 26th, 2010 at 5:30 pm
it didn’t read like a story… it’s like preaching, or confession, or a log.
sorry i didn’t like it.
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 6:20 pm
Excellent story. I have the same views about life. If you dont get a good grade that teacher is bogus. lol. Its glad to see their our other people who share the same thoughts about life. Goodluck!
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 6:56 pm
welll, I guess it was good… for a school thing anyway. I only reccomend you take out NASA and Discovery Channel. I just think it’s a litt e tacky to put such proper nouns into any kind of writing. Almost like putting Nike or Adidas or CBS, just doesn’t sounds good. You can use a noun instead, like television; for example:
I saw it all the time on the Discovery Channel
I saw it all the time on tv.
I could find them in National Geographic.
I could see them in pictures.
It gives it that vague, mysterious quality you know? People get to tired of hearing exact details after a while, then again exact details didn’t hurt 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (there’s a lot of proper nouns and measurements in that book XD )
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 7:03 pm
Your descriptions were really good, but maybe it was a little repetitive here and there. i liked the idea of the story, and how it flowed together quite well. your concepts were interesting too!
you should get a really good grade for that
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 7:53 pm
It didnt feel much like astory but rather a memoir, even a bit like Twilight maybe, im guessing you have read it with the writing style that you are using. I love how your describing the stars but you need to think of the five senses when you describe something. Maybe describe the wind and how it hit your cheeks and how you felt warm or something and that the smell of pine was rising with every gust. All you are saying is I saw or I could. Try starting those sentences with the or just an noun and instead of saw or could replace it with something more interesting like The glimpse of …. or if you want to keep I then use I gazed at… Also you need to have a beginning middle and end this is just three paragraphs about one moment NO PLOT to have a story there needs to be a plot the character doesnt just think or just say their feelings unless its to get the story moving… THE STORY IS NOT MOBILE! get it to MOVE!
PS- I just noticed to whole Narrative thing so here’s my comment on that:
A personal narrative is an event I understand that just glimpsing at the stars is an event but really? is just looking up at the sky gonna be sufficient enough to grasp the readers attention in a narrative, its like a memoir, your not going to remember everything add something to conclude why you would even remember such a thing but put it as dialogue or a thought that runs through your mind.
I hope I wasnt too harsh but I always love constructive critizism soo here’s my gift to you.
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 8:15 pm
That was so good!!!!!
References :
April 26th, 2010 at 8:41 pm
I believe that we were born to be here in this time, this moment, this place…
Your opener got my attention. Very good opener.
Then you veered off the path. Do I have to travel to the Amazon to see stars..is this what the Amazon offers?
Amazon rain forest, teeming with life…..what kind?
turquoise and faded white we call the Milky Way — that kept me entranced. I’d never seen anything like it…..nice construction. I began to see what you saw.
we gave up trying to find words to exchange; we fell silent. ..hmmmm nice,nice.
I tried to remember what exactly had caused the prolonged pause… Hey! you wandered again! Great flow, here! ..but.. What exactly had caused the prolonged pause??
Maybe I worry too much about the past, regretting, or maybe I worry too much about the future. When did regret get me anywhere? When did worrying about the trivial things help me out in the end? At some point, everyone realizes how foolish it is to constantly look ……..
hmmmmm! you are doing it again! You have opened a very intriguing door for me and then shut it….tell me more about yourself, here. Why are you at the Amazon basin
if you just stop for a moment, however briefly, and look, you’ll be able to see the stars…Wow! Where would that put me if I read more?
You have talent as distant as those stars..and as close as their light.
You need to stand on the banks of "self" and take a moment to see the stars in you that I do…sometimes we stumble through a darkness looking for stars..like yours.
References :
That is how it looks from my Jungle.
April 26th, 2010 at 8:46 pm
That was really good!!! =))) the way you wrote the story set the mood perfectly!!! Description and organization was excellent!!! Great job!!!! you should get a good grade with this =))
References :